For many years, I labored in my house and yard to make it our home. We planted trees and bushes and flower beds and vegetable gardens. We cleaned gutters and pressure washed and hung birdhouses. We painted and wired and watered and painted again. We created a pet graveyard All those years and all those chores, we tried to involve our children, not only to teach them how to care for and maintain things, but also to give them a sense of ownership. The first part worked well enough, but the second part: forget it! They didn’t see these things as belonging to them, so what they did were just chores.
Now, two of my children are homeowners. What a difference! They are painting and fixing up and doing all those things they learned how to do long ago, but did not like and couldn’t wait to leave behind. Now that they are homeowners themselves, well—that makes all the difference. Pride of ownership. It makes us work very hard without any other motivation than the investment itself. Why is it so hard to find good help? Because help is not a form of ownership.
Shepherds are property owners. Sheep are the property of shepherds and they are even tougher to own than real estate. When you own real estate, you have plumbing to fix and grass to cut and flower beds to weed and gutters to clean. Being a homeowner takes a lot of perseverance keeping up with the maintenance, but no one dies when you don’t get the painting done. When you are a shepherd, the story can be quite different. In the sheep business, a shepherd has not only the elements and the weather and wild animals to contend with; he also has to deal with thieves and robbers.
In the tenth chapter of John, Jesus describes himself as both a door for the sheep and as their shepherd—a good shepherd. People knew exactly what Jesus meant when he described himself as the door to his sheep. In those days, a shepherd would gather his flock for the night. There might have been some sort of enclosure. There would be only one opening and there the shepherd would sleep, so that the only legitimate way in or out was through him.
There are good shepherds and there are bad shepherds. Jesus mentions thieves, robbers and hirelings as examples of bad shepherds. There are thieves and robbers in the religion business too. The only difference is that generally they come well dressed and well rehearsed with a pitch designed to sell their product. In Jesus’ day, they took the form of miracle men and false prophets.
A bad shepherd would allow others to come in or he would run away under threat of danger. In his book While Shepherds Watch Their Flocks, Timothy Laniak gives us this thought to ponder about modern day shepherds: “One of the great ironies in the world of shepherds—whether literal or figurative—is that the best thieves are good shepherds. Not good in the sense that Jesus was. But extraordinarily effective in gaining a following.”
The best “thieves” have always been the most difficult to recognize. They deal in money and power and preach prosperity as a way to draw us into their false gospel. Sometimes they come disguised in the name of this or that brand of politics or this or that brand of freedom. Jesus is the gatekeeper that prevents the entry of these thieves into our churches and homes. He protects us from their influence. If we listen, we will hear his voice above the din of their empty promises.
There is another kind of bad shepherd. He is the hired hand. Usually, he will not defraud or cheat, although sometimes he will steal from his boss. That’s why even today it is not uncommon for an owner to ask for proof of the death of a sheep by showingits hide or some other proof. For these same reasons we should ask our modern day shepherds to be accountable to us for their activities. The hireling will not risk life or limb for his sheep. The hired hand is there for the money and the money is not nearly good enough to make him risk loss. He flees at the sign of danger and the sheep must shift for themselves. The hireling, like the Scribes and Pharisees of first century Israel , is more concerned with his safety and preserving the status quo than he is for those under his charge. The hireling, like some pastors and many leadership boards of churches and corporations, is more concerned with not rocking the boat than with finding a new generation for Christ. It’s bloody and messy to stick around and fight. It’s risky to witness the gospel with no concern for how you might be viewed by strangers or employers. And for what? A few sheep who can’t take care of themselves?
Shepherds don’t think like that. Sheep are their livelihood. As surely as sheep feed the families of shepherds, so do shepherds look after that which brings them their sustenance. The sheep trust their shepherd and the true shepherd will not betray that trust. A man’s house is his “castle” and the law says he can use even deadly force to defend it. That was the way shepherds looked at their sheep. Twice in this passage Jesus refers to himself as the Good Shepherd. Twice he says to his listeners, “I lay down my life for my sheep.”
Jesus tells us in verse 14 that he knows his sheep and his sheep know him. Just as the sound of the shepherd’s voice was distinctive to his sheep, so is the presence of the Holy Spirit as it guides us through Scripture and the Word proclaimed in the midst of all the voices of would-be wisdom in our world today. He knows us. We are his sheep and he knows us. We know his voice when we hear it. It is the only voice that we can follow with all our hearts and all our minds and all our souls and all our strength. Our job is to surrender to the leadership of the Good Shepherd and let his voice lead us through the darkness. Knowing him and responding to his voice means that we can follow him, and that we will have the discernment to ignore the false messages in the crowd.
There are others to come into the flock. Jesus tells us that there are “other sheep not of this fold.” He says that he must bring them also, that they too will listen to his voice, that they too will become part of his flock. In the first century, that call to other sheep must surely have been to the Gentiles, of whom we are numbered. But what of today? Are there still other sheep? Look at these empty pews and you have your answer. Leave now and go to area restaurants already full and you have your answer. There are still many sheep not of this fold and our Savior wants them all. This is why he came. This is why he trained his disciples. This is why the church witnesses through proclamation of Word and Sacrament in every corner of the world. And to that our Savior says: “So there will be one flock, one shepherd.”
There’s an old saying: “We have met the enemy and they are us.” Do we take too much pride in doing things the way they have always been done? Do we feel a little too much ownership in the contributions we make of our time and talents? There’s more than one way to become a wolf or a thief. Dr. Laniak says that “Becoming a wolf only takes a combination of skepticism and time. Values shift almost imperceptibly …Unfortunately, good shepherds sometimes become wolves without realizing their own transformation. They become captive to ideas that they once resisted.” It happened to church leaders in Jerusalem . The religious leaders of Jesus’ day were well meaning but badly misguided men who made some very bad choices. Paul, the greatest church planter of them all, warns his flock in Ephesus to:
Be on guard for yourselves and all the flock…to
shepherd the church of God which he purchased
with his own blood. I know that…wolves will come
in among you, not sparing the flock…and from
among you…men will arise…to draw away the
disciples after them. [Acts 20: 28-31]
It happens today as well. The enemy can be us. If we settle for watered down theology, we teach what is false. We fleece ourselves. If we do not hear and respond to the distinctive voice of the Good Shepherd, it is we who will take the flock away from the very Owner who commissioned us to pastor or teach or till this great garden of humanity we call the church. As Paul says, it has been bought with a price—the blood of Christ himself.
The Psalmist sings to us:
For he is our God,
and we are the people of his pasture,
and the sheep of his hand. [Psalm 95: 7]
It’s a serious responsibility to be able to keep recognizing the wolves out there—or in here. It is an inconvenient truth that we are our own worst enemy. Only belief in and obedience to Jesus can break that cycle. In a world full of bad shepherds, he is the good one. It takes a priesthood of believers to keep the message clean and clear. But it’s worth it, don’t you think? Jesus sure thought so. He laid down his life…for his sheep.