At Christmas time, we celebrated the birth of Jesus, the Messiah. This is called the Incarnation. A few weeks later, we marked the Epiphany, the time generally associated by Roman Catholics and Protestants with the visit of the Magi. I know what the manger scene looks like. That’s okay. Many of our traditions are off a little on some of the timing or detail. The Eastern Church identifies the baptism of Jesus by John, rather than the visit of the Magi, as the Epiphany. The word means “manifestation,” so really either event could work as an epiphany. I think of the Epiphany this way. It’s a coming out party for Jesus, at least for those who are privileged to be there.
In a way the story of Jesus’ first miracle in the Gospel of John is a continuation of that coming out party. It is his first time to show others something of what he is capable of. The timing of the miracle is bothersome to Jesus, for all the gospels assert that Jesus did not want his true identity revealed prematurely. For instance, in today’s passage, Jesus, when called upon by his mother to perform this miracle, says that his “time” has not yet come. Nevertheless, Jesus decides to come to the rescue.
The story seems a little odd. Most of Jesus’ miracles involve either healing or taming nature. He heals the sick, gives sight to the blind, makes cripples walk. He walks on water and calms storms. He feeds the multitude and raises people from death. In that context, the turning of water into wine at a wedding feast doesn’t seem to fit. In fact, this miracle story is unique to John’s gospel. It does not appear in the others. But John’s gospel is not like the others. John goes his own way, tells his own story. John’s gospel is not so much about mighty acts as it is about theology and Christology and relationships. For instance, Matthew relates twenty different miracle events, while John tells only six. The first and last of those miracles that John does narrate are unique to his gospel. The last one is the story of the raising of Lazarus from the dead, literally from the grave, all told in the context of Jesus being the resurrection and the life. It may be the most incredible, most uplifting of all the miracles stories of Jesus. The bookend to this is John’s first narrated miracle, turning water into wine at a wedding feast. If Lazarus is the greatest, the wine thing might be the most obscure, the most easy to dismiss of the miracle stories.
Yet, there it is. The writer of John’s gospel is thought to have been John, the beloved disciple, a member of Jesus’ inner circle, the great gospel theologian. He lived the longest of the Twelve, thought to have still been alive in the 90’s. He had sixty years since Christ’s death and resurrection to think about what he wanted to write. He almost certainly had access to the Synoptic gospels (Matthew, Mark and Luke) and to Paul’s letters. It makes no sense to think other than that he wanted every single line to bring meaning and richness and depth to the gospel story he wrote at the end of his days about his friend and Savior. What is John saying to us in this, the first miracle of Jesus’ brand new ministry?
Cana was about nine miles north of Nazareth, the village where Jesus grew up. According to John, Jesus is probably in his first week of ministry and has at this point picked up five of his disciples. We should assume that they are accompanying him. He has come back home, perhaps to attend the wedding feast of a neighbor. This is one of the few times we hear from Mary since the birth of Jesus, and she seems to be surprisingly assertive here. She says to Jesus: “They have no wine.” I can almost see that look. She knows what Jesus is capable of. She knows what is needed. She looks at her son and she says “they have no wine.” Jesus looks at her and says in essence, “Come on, mom. You know it’s not time yet. This isn’t for me.” To which the sainted mother of our Savior simply looks to the servants and says “Do whatever he tells you.” You don’t have to be a Bible scholar to figure out what is on Mary’s mind. Some commentaries say that this is not the story of a son doing his mother’s bidding. I think I might be tempted to qualify that to say that it’s not just that kind of story. Of course there is more to it than that, but I still get the feeling that there is a son here who wants to do his mother’s bidding as well.
There is an old legend that might explain why Mary was so invested here and why she seemed to have authority to tell the servants to do what Jesus told them to do. One of the Coptic gospels that didn’t make the cut for the New Testament claims that Mary was a sister of the bridegroom’s mother. In fact, in an early set of prefaces to the New Testament called the Monarchian Prefaces, it was asserted that the bridegroom was actually John himself, and that his mother was Salome, the sister of Mary. These are not provable facts, but they make for some interesting possible explanations. The fact that John was one of those first five disciples called makes John an eyewitness at the very least.
While all of that is interesting, it still doesn’t explain why this particular miracle story is included in John’s gospel. I don’t think he was just taking a trip down memory lane, even if the legends are true. It has often been said about John that his gospel must be read on two levels. There is always the story itself, which never fails to instruct, and which is easy enough to understand on its face. But there is almost always the story within the story. Certainly that theory is at work here in the wedding feast miracle at Cana .
The miracle is actually part of a larger section of John that takes place in Cana and is described over the course of chapters 2-4. Theologian Craig Blomberg calls this section “The Newness of Jesus’ Ministry.” William Barclay calls it “The New Exhilaration.” In those three chapters, there are six stories. The miracle with the water and wine is the first. It is followed by the cleansing of the temple, the meeting of Jesus with Nicodemus, the question of the supremacy of Jesus over John the Baptist, the meeting of Jesus with the Samaritan woman and the healing of the Nobleman’s son. Again, all these events are sandwiched into these three chapters where John talks about events in Cana or while Jesus was in and around Cana . In subsequent chapters, Jesus moves to Judea and away from Cana , but here John uses these stories to paint the big picture. Taken together as a unit, they point to the newness that is taking place in God’s people and in how they will come to be defined.
The Cana segment starts with Jesus turning water into wine. This represents a new joy, not only at the wedding feast, but in the coming of the author of the miracle. He has come to open the world to a new ministry. This is the new age, and it is represented by a new worship since the Son of God has cleansed the temple. It is also represented by a new birth, says Jesus to Nicodemus. To enter God’s kingdom, one must be born again, by water and the Spirit. John the Baptist is important as a segway to Jesus, but he represents the old and Jesus represents the new. He comes not to change the law but to finally fulfill it in the way that our heavenly Father always intended. Then, in chapter 4, we see the stories of the Samaritan woman and the Nobleman’s son, a mixed race woman and a Gentile being healed or included by Jesus. Now we see that the inclusiveness of Jesus’ message and his new ministry are unquestionably universal. They include not only Samaritans and Gentiles, but also the lowest and the most outcast of society. No one who believes will be turned away from God’s kingdom. This is a revolutionary message revealed in this new ministry for the ages. It is a greater grace than the Law could have ever afforded and it is being introduced here in Cana .
The Cana narrative and the discourses it contains are instructive for our church. We have been here for a long time. We have built, maintained and preserved. All those attributes are good and endearing and important. But there is and should always be a new ministry rising up from within the old story. Core truths never change, but customs do. Bedrock values never move, but practices do. We find our habits moving and changing in response to the changes around us. We celebrate that very ability to grow today as we welcome the ordination of a new elder in this church.
Change is not our enemy; it is our companion. Our challenge is to continue to worship, continue to witness in a society whose values can sometimes be compared to quicksand. Such is not the stuff of the church. Our values do not move. We change our style to achieve the spread of the gospel. We are God’s people. Jesus came to claim us and make our salvation possible. Like the new ministry that Jesus introduced at Cana , we look for new life in our own ministries. We celebrate our opportunity to add new leaders, new ideas, new life to the Church of Jesus Christ .
So the miracle at Cana was not just any old miracle. It was not just a favor to a beloved mother. It was the first miracle of our Lord on earth in a new ministry that would change the world. And, thank God, he was just getting started!